Imagine our if our textbooks preached hate, murder and bigotry like the Palestinian Muslims. Be thankful you live in America.
by Ken Cohen
There was great hope and anticipation several years ago when the Palestinian Authority announced that it was completely replacing its K-12 school textbooks. But new editions merely confirm obsessive Palestinian hatred of Jews and rejection of peace with Israel.
The older Palestinian textbooks had been filled with ugly anti-Zionist—and anti-Semitic—propaganda. Shockingly, this pervasive spirit of distortion and hate wasn’t only employed in history textbooks, but also dominated language, math and even science lessons.
The original PA textbooks had been in use for about twenty years, having been published following the Oslo Accords. (Prior to that, Palestinian schools had continued to use the Jordanian textbooks that were published before the 1967 Six-Day War.)
Over the past three years, the PA has released the full set of new textbooks, and they are even worse than the old ones in teaching Jew-hatred, a fictionalized narrative of history, and a profound glorification of martyrdom, terrorism and hate. Though Western liberals continue to place the onus of peace-making on Israel, these materials make clear that the Palestinians continue to wage war.
Recently, the organization Institute for Monitoring Peace and Cultural Tolerance in School Education (IMPACT-se) has published its reports on the textbooks—replete with examples—that demonstrate the horrific indoctrination being inflicted on Palestinian youth by their educators.
Geography, of course, is taught without reference to Israel’s borders—or even the State of Israel’s existence. All of the maps and exercises are predicated on a state of Palestine with its borders extending from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea, and from Lebanon to Egypt. Israel is completely obliterated throughout the textbooks, although the Palestinian textbooks are rife with references to “Zionist occupiers” and “Zionist-Jews.”
The Israeli city of Haifa is treated as “occupied territory”—every bit as “occupied” as the disputed areas of Judea and Samaria which fell under Israeli control in June of 1967. So while much of the world considers the issue of the eventual disposition of “the West Bank” to be the crux of the Arab-Israeli conflict, yet another generation of Palestinian kids in PA-administered schools are being indoctrinated to believe that the only satisfactory resolution of the situation is the total overthrow and expulsion of the “Zionist usurpers” from every square inch of “Palestine.”
In 2nd-grade Language, the children learn this:
I am a lion cub, I’m a flower/we gave our spirits to the revolution
Our grandfathers built houses/for us in our free country
I am a lion cub, I’m a flower/we carried the revolution’s flame
To Haifa, to Jaffa / to Al-Aqsa / to Jerusalem’s Dome of the Rock.
But the perfidious nature of the Palestinian textbooks extends well beyond geography or even a history that is largely fictional. Throughout the math and science textbooks, problems and exercises are structured around the purported evils of the “Zionist occupation,” including even first- and second-grade math textbooks. Math exercises include comparing the number of “martyrs” in the first and second intifadas, and what percentage of those shot by Israeli soldiers in the Gaza uprisings were elevated to “martyrdom.”
Consider this excerpt from the 4th-grade Mathematics textbook:
The number of martyrs of the First Intifada (the Intifada of Rocks) is 2026 martyrs, and the number of martyrs of the Al-Aqsa Intifada is 5,050. The number of martyrs in the two intifadas is _________ martyrs.
Newton’s laws of gravity are illustrated in science textbooks using the functioning and lethality of slingshots used by would-be “martyrs.” Anatomy and the functions of different organs are described in terms of the happy adrenalin surge experienced by martyrs in their last moments. The effects of “Zionist oppressor” bullets on various body parts are thoroughly explored.
Here is a lesson from the new 7th-grade Science textbook:
Newton’s Second Law:
During the first Palestinian uprising, Palestinian youths used slingshots to confront the soldiers of the Zionist Occupation and defend themselves from their treacherous bullets.
What is the relationship between the elongation of the slingshot’s rubber and the tensile strength affecting it? What are the forces that influence the stone after its release from the slingshot? What safety precautions should be taken into account when using the slingshot?
The essential thrust of the Literature and Language Palestinian textbooks is the glorification of martyrdom and jihad as unqualified virtues. Poetry extolling the virtues of suicide bombers and homicidal terrorists are frequent. This is from the 3rd-grade text, which is entitled “Our Beautiful Language”:
We sing and remember: The Land of the Generous
I vow I shall sacrifice my blood, to saturate the land of the generous and will eliminate the usurper from my country, and will annihilate the remnants of the foreigners . Oh the land of Al-Aqsa and the Haram, oh cradle of chivalry and generosity Patient, be patient as victory is ours, dawn is emerging from the oppression.
Dalal al-Mughrabi, the homicidal woman who orchestrated the 1978 Coastal Road massacre that murdered 38 Israelis—including a dozen Jewish children—is a highlighted heroine in a number of Palestinian textbooks, including this 5th-grade Language textbook:
Our Palestinian history is brimming with names of martyrs who have given their lives to the homeland, including the martyr Dalal al-Mughrabi. Her struggle portrays challenge and heroism, making her memory immortal in our hearts and minds.
The same textbook includes a list of Palestinian heroes to emulate and worship. All of them are terrorists. The list includes no scientists, no doctors, no engineers, no singers, no athletes, nor any artists .
In what one might grimly consider a feminist virtue of the new Palestinian textbooks, girls are called to participate fully in the jihad, and not to hesitate in making themselves into “holy martyrs.”
But these teaching materials do not merely present a perverse political philosophy, they also convey blanket falsehoods to erase Jewish history and support exclusive Palestinian claims to all of the Holy Land.
Thus, Jewish culture and history in “Palestine” are, not surprisingly, completely expunged. According to the Palestinian textbooks, any Jewish presence in the area has existed only in the last century, when synagogues were first built by the Zionist invaders, and the al-Buraq wall—built by Arabs in honor of the Prophet Muhammad’s horse—was renamed and co-opted by Zionists as “the Wailing Wall.”
Since—according to the Palestinian textbooks—there were never any Jewish Temples in Jerusalem, the Western Wall is clearly another Zionist-Jewish invention of recent vintage.
The Palestinian “phased plan” to eliminate the Zionist cancer from Palestine—which is still in the PLO charter—is diligently taught throughout the curriculum.
Yet the primary concern of the PA’s Minister of Education, Sabri Saidam is that Israel refuses to use these Palestinian textbooks in Arab-majority schools in Israel or the disputed territories, particularly in Jerusalem. Saidam insists that Israel’s use of versions of the Israeli curriculum for Arab-Israeli kids is “an ugly crime of counterfeit” perpetrated by the “Zionist oppressors.”
Great Britain and the European Union have contributed hundreds of millions to the development and propagation of the Palestinian textbooks and curriculum, but that may be drawing to a close: Both polities are doing their own reviews of the Palestinian textbooks. Each has laws outlawing aid in furtherance of terrorism, incitement, violence and hatred. Their reports are due later this year, and by all rights should spell the end of UK and EU furtherance of this despicable educational charade.
Those who doubt any imminent resolution of the Arab-Israeli conflict need look no further than these Palestinian textbooks to become even more pessimistic about a new Palestinian generation leading the way—at long last—to a peaceful future for Arabs and Jews alike. These unfortunate children are being brainwashed by their elders to seek no compromise, but to continue on the suicidal path of terror, hate and ignorance so well established by past generations of Palestinian Arabs and their leaders.
As you discuss Israel’s prospects for peace with their Palestinian Arab neighbors in the Middle East, I urge you to emphasize that peace requires two partners—and the Palestinians clearly show more inclination to make wat than peace. Make your associates aware of the travesty of the PA’s education system, and ensure that they understand that the Palestinian Arab leadership has opted to propagate a dreadful, blood-soaked future for its youth.
One other urgent issue for pro-Israel activists: This week the House of Representatives is scheduled to consider a bipartisan resolution (HR 246) to oppose BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions). Please call your Representative to push for a vote supporting this resolution, which puts Congress on record opposing the anti-Israel—and anti-Semitic—BDS campaign.
Please take a minute right now, while you have this phone number in front of you: Call (212) 224-3121 and ask for your Representative’s office. Here’s a sample script: “I’m calling to urge the Representative to push for a vote to support the bipartisan anti-BDS House resolution 246 when it comes to the floor this week. I oppose discrimination against the Jewish state.”
In addition to supporting this anti-BDS measure, I hope you’ll also take a minute, while you have this material front and center, to visit FLAME’s lively new Facebook page and review the P.S. immediately below. It describes FLAME’s new hasbarah campaign—a refutation of the myth of “Palestinian territories.”
Best regards,
Ken Cohen
Editor, Facts and Logic About the Middle East (FLAME)
You and yours make me sick.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/29/us/gilroy-california-food-festival-shooting-monday/index.html
Libby – Once again, I must ask for clarification? What did I do to make you sick today? Was it something in this article or was something related to the shooting link you posted? Please note, I didn’t shoot anyone, I didn’t endorse shooting anyone, I don’t know the shooter. I really have no connection to Gilroy other than my cousin lives there. So what is it Libs, what did I do that has you feeling sick?
You’ve not been stupid, Jack, til now. Your islamophobes, your white supremacists, they are all of a piece, your people, and despicable. You and Tina, the King and Queen of Denial.
You plainly have not realized, but The Donald has plunked himself down beyond the pale … and you too … or so it would seem.
Rand Paul’s excellent suggestion and offer to Ilhan Omar:
https://start.att.net/news/read/article/newser-rand_paul_floats_controversial_idea_for_ilhan_omar-rnewsernor/category/news
Looks like those white nationalist newsletters weren’t the only racist trash Ron Paul shot out without thinking.
We are not born hating. That’s something that is taught. So guess who the REAL haters are!
So how long do you suppose it will take? … for the Trumpsters to realize that public manifestations of the Trumpian mindset will get you 1) sacked (stuffed animals) or 2) killed (assault rifle).
In the meantime … sickening.
Libby, exactly what do you propose to end the killings of innocent people by crazies? What’s the utopian fix here that would have stopped this guy from his murderous rage? More gun laws? Change the zoning, to a gun free zone? Perhaps you would ban all guns, but then you would have to ban all forms of improvised explosive devices, ban knives and box cutters, ban all cars larger than a Volkswagen, so they can’t be used to mow down people just to be safe. How about a psychological screening test from the time a child enters kindergarten until they are adults and then do midnight raids on homes to lock up the children until we get their minds right?
I bet you could find a way for us all to be safe, but would any of us really want to live in that kind of world? I wouldn’t.
By the way did you know there are between 22,000 and 30,000 gun laws on the books in America? Those laws include restrictions on possession, carry, distribution, storage, transfer, manufacture, sale, ownership, importation, use and more. How’s that working out for us?
Libby, exactly what do you propose to end the killings of innocent people by crazies?
Jack, you’re asking this question in the comments to a post you wrote about how a toxic, racist ideology is poisoning minds and driving people to violence. So don’t you already know the answer? Target the toxic ideology.
The Gilroy shooter was a white nationalist. Now, I would not go as far as Libby in conflating him with “you and yours,” but I will point out that I have been raising alarms about the links between white nationalists and the mainstream right in general on this blog for over a decade now, and the response from you and yours has been a resounding “Meh, no big deal.” When I’ve pointed out times in which you’ve inadvertently cited white nationalist websites here, the response has mostly been a shrug of the shoulders. A few weeks ago when I pointed out that Laura Ingraham promoted Holocaust-loving Paul Nehlen on her show as a victim of unfair social media censorship, I was attacked, and no conservative here came to my defense. When I’ve pointed out that language about minorities and immigrants “infesting” or “invading” our country is the same exact rhetoric white nationalists use to justify ethnic cleansing, people here act like I’m the hysterical one. You say nothing even when the President of the United States retweets white nationalists and uses their rhetoric and symbolism.
I agree with you on these textbooks–they’re horrific! And while I put a little more responsibility on Israel then you do, it can’t be denied that Palestinian leadership is run by a terrorist group that only worsens the problem and keeps the cycle of hatred going. But I urge you to consider how racist ideologies are being circulated in our own media right now and how they might be contributing to violence here. The alt-right is growing in its influence and mainstream conservative voices often provide cover for them. If you do not want people to think of the right in general as racists then you need to do exactly as you urge peace-loving Muslims to do about their radicals: call out your own. Be careful about the links you share. Identify the racist and hateful aspects of your movement and speak out against them. Resist the knee-jerk impulse to defend the most radical among you. I do that for mine: I was a very vocal critic of the leadership within the Women’s March due to their support of Farrakhan. I’m upset with many on the left defending Al Sharpton right now despite his history with anti-Semitism, and I’m expressing that on Twitter. Resisting this kind of tribalism is difficult but it is necessary to solve the divisions that plague us all over the world.
The Gilroy shooter was a white nationalist. Really, we know that already, huh? Amazing.
That’s your response to my comment? How lazy. Why do I put in the effort at all? You are committed to refusing to take these issues seriously.
Here is the latest on what we know about the Gilroy shooter:
He reportedly identified as Iranian and Italian. Not much was known about the alleged shooter at first, but Heavy.com reportedly found an Instagram account attributed to Santino. It has since been deleted. Heavy.com claims to have obtained screenshots. The alleged account claims that Santino stated he was of Italian and Iranian descent.
2. The alleged shooter reportedly said he was “very angry.” Jack van Breen, the singer for the band Tin Man, was one of the witnesses of the shooting, according to the New York Post. He claims he saw a man in a green shirt and a grayish handkerchief around his neck, wield an “assault rifle” and open fire into a crowded area. The musician dove under the stage when the shooting began and claims he heard someone shout, “Why are you doing this?” The attacker reportedly replied by saying, “Because I’m very angry.”
3. He was killed within minutes after the shooting began. The Gilroy Garlic Festival attracts around 100,000 people to Gilroy, a city 80 miles southeast of San Francisco, over the three-day weekend. The shooting, which took place at 5:40 PM local time, twenty minutes before the festival was set to close, sent hundreds of panicked people scrambling for safety. However, the shooting was practically over as soon as it started. Gilroy Police Chief Scot Smithee told reporters that Gilroy officers engaged a suspect within a minute of shots ringing out and killed him, according to CBS News.
The above is the very latest, best information released by police.
Hmmm….so Chris, you said the shooter was a white nationalist, where did that come from?
Is your Google broken?
https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/instagram-account-connected-gilroy-shooter-pushed-staple-white-supremacist-internet-n1035926
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/gilroy-garlic-festival-shooting-gunman-santino-legan-social-media-post-suggests-white-supremacy-ties/
https://www.newsweek.com/gilroy-shooter-white-supremacist-manifesto-instagram-1451586
Peggy said, My high school years 1962-66, didn’t have drugs other than smoking where your parents or any adult would see you. Sneaking a couple of beers from the frig was the worst any of us ever did. Today’s drug problem is a crisis compared to mine and Jack’s generation.
Yep, absolutely agree.
You put this comment in the wrong place, Jack.
I can’t place comments, it’s done automatically.
Jack. Read. I am telling you that you wrote a comment on the wrong article.
Ok, thanks Chris.
Ah … forgot the latest link:
https://www.cnn.com/2019/07/30/politics/transportation-security-administration-racist-display/index.html
Re: “Hmmm….so Chris, you said the shooter was a white nationalist, where did that come from?”
Where everything from Chris comes from. His *ss.
I just gave three different links pointing out this fact. You could have easily found it on your own. Are you really that deep in the right-wing media bubble?
Jack is King, Tina Queen, and Pie is Jester in The Land of Denial.
Detachment is a marvelous thing, and I will be working very hard to maintain some, so that maybe, if Trump keeps this racist cant going all the way to the election, and he wins, … I can be amused.
Or maybe sickened unto death.
You’d think the release of tapes of Reagan calling black people “monkeys” would make them think a bit about the racial dogwhistles Democrats (and even Republicans) have been calling out from Republicans for the last several decades. But if they haven’t heard that the Gilroy shooter was a white nationalist than they probably haven’t heard about this either. Safe spaces, and all that.